Saturday, May 1, 2010

Website Worthy, Worth Viewing?

After looking at multiple online news sites, I assumed that all news sites had
relatively the same news stories, and they do. For the most part, all of the sites
have the same information available to viewers at first glance. However, I wondered
if their placement and the size of their headline had anything to do with the
broadcasters perceived importance of the data.

I compared three websites, foxnews.com, cnn.com, and msnbc.com to see how
their front webpage stories differed and what messages were seemingly sent
to audience members through the placement of the stories on the websites.

Foxnews.com used the largest font for the most stories on their main page.
The most prominent titles on the page were, " Super Soaker,Gulf Oil Spill
Triples in Size, Border fights local Toll, and Obama slams anti-government rhetoric."

Cnn.com had the least number of large font headlines. Majority of their headlines
were centered around the oil spill in the South. Their largest titles on the main page
were, " As oil near Gulf Coast, experts issue dire warnings, and Gulf Coast Volunteers
hurry up, wait." Under these two large font headlines were nine smaller new story articles,
mainly video clips the audience could click on.

Msnbc.com used most of their main page to share information with the public about the
"Gulf Oil Slick balloon in size, could move east, Jockey rides Super Saver to a Kentucky
Derby first, and Is The Nations Highest Court too 'I-95'?"

I wonder how the placement of articles on webpages affects the reader or audience's perception
of their importance. My thoughts are that the media uses big fonts, flashy pictures, and the items
being located front and center to signify their importance and significance. However, I find it
very interesting that particular pages try to shift the audience attention to what they deem is
very important. Foxnews.com obviously thought that race and the oil spill was of great importance
to the readers. Cnn.com thought the oil spill was something the readers needed to know about.
From skimming the stories, the headlines give the audience a positive and negative take on the
oil spill and the progress or lack there of of the clean up efforts. Lastly, msnbc.com seem to have
the most varied headlines with them focusing on the oil spill, derby, and the Supreme Court.

Just an interesting facet to explore, online news title placement sizes and colors.

Dead Man Ridin

http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/offbeat/2010/04/29/moos.dead.man.poses.on.bike.cnn?hpt=C2

Jeanne Moos takes the liberty in this video clip from cnn.com to share the story of final
wishes of the deceased while capturing the response of the public to those wishes.
In this video clip, titled "Dead Man Ridin'" a 22 year old victim of gun crime requested
his burial be on the motorcycle his uncle had given him years back. He is posed on the
motorcycle like he is riding it through the country side. His deadly look is finished of with
sunglasses and bike riding attire. Photographs of this very believable scene are then
shown to the public where reactions vary. Some women are appalled by the man being
dead and on a motorcycle and say things to Moos like "that's gross" while making
horrid faces at the images.

The man was prepared by a special funeral parlor in Puerto Rico. After sharing this
information, Jeanne explains to the audience that the body must be "stiff enough
to stay in the position but able to lay back in a coffin." This is fairly gruesome language
when having to apply it to the actual person they are talking about. In addition, to this
the video clip shows Jeanne on the phone with the morgue that prepared the 22 year
old victim. When asked how they do this, she shares that is it something along the lines
of a "very special secret." They then show images of other dead people, one propped up
in the corner smiling, and then advertise for unique coffins that can be purchase in Europe.

The ending of this video clip has a woman completely bothered by the images and
telling the anchor she has to go or she will be late after finding out the man on the
bike was dead. Majority of the reactions capture were that of women. Perhaps women
were selected for a more expected dramatic response to the images and the oppor
tunity people have to be buried in this manner. Perhaps the interview was slightly
bias in the fact the woman interviewing was primarily capturing women's opinion
of the two oddly buried men.

Perhaps if the women were shown images of other women buried in non-traditional
way then they could/would have reacted differently to the scenario. Maybe if a woman
saw another woman knitting, crocheting, in the kitchen, etc,. it would ease the horrid
expressions and opinions of the women.

Nonetheless, this video clip is intriguing and makes the audience curious about the
process and likelihood of this becoming a popular fad. It paints the picture of men being
overly ambitious and leaving with style and women as the more traditional burial candidate.


The Oil Spill Runneth Over

In addition to a previous blog entry about the oil spill in Louisiana, I feel compelled to write another entry about the severity of the event. This oil spill is making history every single minute. Oil continues to pour into the Gulf of Mexico and splash against the coastline of Louisiana. I fear that there is not much hope for the State of Louisiana. Granted, I try to be optimistic in these situations, but after reading the article, "Gulf oil spill balloon, could move east" by Allen Breed and Seth Borenstein of msnbc.com, I fear that any seafood lover should eat it tonight because tomorrow may be too late.

The tone of this article is both informative and sends audience members a sense of urgency about this issue. The article notes that BP and the government seemingly underestimated the severity of this problem and waiting too long to improve cleanup efforts. This article attempts to capture the heartfelt sadness and concern of many Louisianians. Our culture and many people's livelihoods are about to come to an unexpected and abrupt ending. According to the article, Matt O'Brien a shrimp docker feels that " These people, we've been beaten down, disaster after disaster." My thoughts are he is making a reference to Hurricanes Katrina and Rita and their damaging effects. In addition, he shares about his workers and other have come to him and ask him "What is going to happen?" He shares that "They come asking me what I think's going to happen. I ain't got no answers for them. I ain't got no answers for my investors. I ain't got no answers." I cannot help but think that his frames this individual as some sort of "typical Southerner" for using the word "ain't" but at the same time, I think it frames this man to the audience as someone that really is just hopeless and uncertain.

This uncertainty is carried throughout the rest of the article by quotes from the BP chief operating officer and other notable sources sharing that there is NO way of telling how many gallons which accumulate to barrels of oil are floating out from the rig's connection and into the Gulf at this moment but according to BP's spokesman they were preparing for the "worst-case scenario." "The spill and the spreading is getting so much faster and expanding much quicker than they estimated," said Hans Graber, executive director of the university's Center for Southeastern Tropical Advanced Remote Sensing. "Clearly, in the last couple of days, there was a big change in the size." Continuing this sense of urgency about the future of Louisiana and the surrounding Gulf areas is the fact that this is going to ruin many people's livelihood.

Shrimping, fishing, and swamps are what draws tourists to Louisiana and the South. Without these attainabilities, the revenues for the state of Louisiana and surrounding areas are almost guaranteed to take a hit. Not only will food options be affected as a result of this spill, but according to the article the environment and culture of the South are not the only portions that will be affected. If the oil reaches the Gulf Stream, it could possibly travel around Florida and up the East Coast which would make this one of the worst disasters the United States has ever seen. There is a portion of this article that sums up the fears quite well while emphasizing both the severity and urgency of this event. The article states, "The concerns are both environmental and economic. The fishing industry is worried that marine life will die — and that no one will want to buy products from contaminated water anyway. Tourism officials are worried that vacationers won't want to visit oil-tainted beaches. And environmentalists are worried about how the oil will affect the countless birds, coral and mammals in and near the Gulf."

The ending of the article is one of the most touching. Perhaps because its sets up a picture for the audience of the uncertainty and fear of these Louisianians. The authors introduce Jimmy Rowell, a 61-year old, third generation oyster and shrimp fisherman with his closing words about the future, ""It's over for us. If this oil comes ashore, it's just over for us," Rowell said angrily, rubbing his forehead. "Nobody wants no oily shrimp." Again, the authors makes sure his improper grammar get into the article, profiling Louisianians as possible idiots. But somehow this publication of improper grammar also touches the heart strings of the audience by portraying the shrimpers and fishermen as someone unintelligent and dependent on the only thing they know (fishing, shrimping, etc,.) to survive.

The combination of the uncertainty from big whig title holders, the improper grammar of individuals losing their livelihood, and the language of uncertainty about the future frame this story and accident as one of utmost concern and attention from the American people.

Saturday, April 24, 2010

More to the inside than what meets the eyes

http://www.cnn.com/2010/LIVING/04/24/antwone.fisher.tie.book/index.html

This morning, Jason Hanna posted an article on cnn.com called "Antoine Fisher: What guys need to know to be men." The story essentially provides boys with ways to be better men. I think almost instantaneously I am aggravated by stories trying to inform the masses of what a man or woman has to do to be more of a man or woman. What are these stereotypes besides pathetic norms that society, heavily influenced by media and its images create? This article in particular catches my attention because it talks all about the outside and looking polished and pristine on the outside without giving much care to the internal care that needs to take places to be a better human being, regardless of gender.

According to this article, Fisher has written a book called, " "A Boy Should Know How to Tie a Tie: And Other Lessons for Succeeding in Life." Fisher claims that young men are longing for someone to teach them how to live, tie a tie, shake hands. From this article, it makes it sound like if a young man does not tie a tie how he thinks he should or shake hands with as much power or force that Fisher wants that he will have a problematic and troublesome life. In this interview, Hanna asks Fisher,

CNN: Your advice on hygiene goes beyond just making sure you shower. You give specific advice, for example, about taking care of yourself well with an excellent shave: one with shaving oil, self-mixed shaving cream, a shaving mug and hot, damp towels. You say a proper, ritualistic shave is a highlight of manhood. How so?

Fisher: I discovered this shaving system called the Art of Shaving. I'd never used oil on my face before I shaved. And then I discovered this shaving system, and I used the oil [in addition to shaving cream], and I realized that it did make the razor glide more smoothly over my skin, and I didn't have any irritation. It was enjoyable, and it had a little scent to it. It's just like anything you do when put your effort into it before you present yourself, and you're clean, well-trimmed. Even if no one mentions it, you know you put the time in to present yourself as best you can. It being part of manhood, you had better enjoy [shaving], because you're going to be doing it for the rest of your life. And I think knowing how to do it and having nice products to help you with it, it makes it enjoyable. And when you use these products, it makes you feel like you're worth it.

Basically this entire article sends the message to the audience that looks is what matters. As a result of a troublesome childhood, Fisher believes it necessary to always look great. This sends the message to audience members that perfecting the outside will fix internal problems. Perhaps perfecting the outside does nothing but mask the internal problems that people have, especially for young men.

Babies having Babies

Yesterday evening I was reading through the title of articles on foxnews.com when I read

one title that caught my eye. It read, " 11 Year old Mexican 'Rape' Victim wants to keep baby." The article was written by Jana Winter on April 23rd. This articles caught my attention for more than one reason: 1) How did an 11 year old get pregnant? 2) Why does it matter that she is Mexican? 3) I will be teaching in a classroom with students around the age of 11, I should immerse myself in the harsh realities of babies having babies.

First off, this young girl lives in Mexico and is the victim of rape. She was raped supposedly by her stepfather when she was 10 resulting in pregnancy. As I continue reading through the article, it shared about Mexico City's abortion law which allows abortions to be done in the first three months of a pregnancy. Because the actual date of conception was unknown, parties for her aborting the unborn baby encourage he to go ahead and have the procedure done. However, the child has decided to keep the baby. It seems that the young girl has become the poster child for abortions in the country to some degree for those advocating legalizing abortions and abortion rights.

However, the story tends to paint the child as a Mother Mary figure. There is not much discussion about what happens to her stepfather other than the mother pressed charges and he is in jail. When interviewing the mother, she mainly just states that "We are keeping the baby." I love that she says it like that, not. We are keeping the baby? Nonetheless, this young 11 year old girl has been taken from her home. The article paints the picture that the family is impoverished and as a result the young girl is being closely monitored and fed lots of nutrients and vitamins to ensure a healthy pregnancy. Instead of the mother showing any sort of remorse about the situation of her daughter, she states in the article that she "isn't sure it was her husband that did this to her daughter."

When they asked the daughter, not the mom what they were going to do, WInter says that "

She said they were asked of their plans and the girl immediately said, “We’re going to have a baby.”

The mother said she was planning on registering the child as her own, then turned to the girl and said, “It’s going to be like a little brother.”

The girl responded, “But it’s going to be my baby anyway.”

I can't help but think perhaps Winter used "immediately" to help readers understand that maybe the girl had been brainwashed to just respond with that answer. Winter follows with her interaction with the child and mother. To some degree, the child must understand that although her mother wants to seemingly cover up her daughter's baby as her little sibling could be an indication that the mother is embarassed. I find it ironic that he 11 year old child says "it's going to be my baby anyway." It is like she (the 11 year old) already has some grasp on the concept that she is pregnant.

Another disturbing portion of this article came when a woman named Mancera, who is helping the child with coping with pregnancy while offering her other options, like adoptions says that "She is very into motherhood." Sure at 11 years old a little girl should be into motherhoood and playing with her dolls, pretending to be their mother, not preganant with one. An 11 year old "being into motherhood" does not make her fit to be a mother. However, as I previously mentioned the article portrays the young girl as confident in her decision and supposedly ready to be a mother. It paints the mother as in denial and attempting to ignore the fact her husband raped her daughter at the age of 10 and then the father is painted as someone who just happens to be behind bars for the incident.

The framing of this article leaves the reader uncertain of what the true focus is. However, each party is framed in a certain light. The daughter is left to deal with an unfortunate circumstance, the mother is too, and the father is being closed off. However, out of sight does not mean out of mind.

Friday, April 23, 2010

GM should stand for Grossly Misleading

Put on your critical lenses! For the past six months, I have immersed myself into classes which offer perspectives about the mass media and the effects of its content and presentation to the multitudes. My eyes have been opened to the power of media to influence people both positively and negatively. I have learned to examine everything in life from a relatively "critical perspective." The word "critical" has a negative connotation to it for the most part, but viewing situations and informations critically is actually a very smart thing to do. I like to think of the word "critical" and interchangeable with the word "careful" or "cautious" perspective. My thoughts anyone can hear something and believe it instantly, essentially taken people's given word without researching any of it. On the other hand, individuals taking time to examine content and information someone hears or what is provided by the media takes discipline and is a necessity for credibility and believability!
To sum this up, it is better to research, here, and receive correct information than just hear and believe.

This blog entry is titled "GM should stand for Grossly Misleading" after viewing a commercial GM shared with the world this past week and reading an article on foxnews.com called "GM Could Be in Hot Water with FTC Over Truth in Advertising." This past week on NBC, and I am sure on other major networks, a commercial aired with Ed Whitacre blasting to the public that his company had paid back their loan from the government in full and five years later. As I watched this 30 seconds of GM glory, I could not help but think, "WOW! GM look at you guys. You must have your stuff together, finally." I did not think too much else about the content of the commercial. I just assumed the number of car sales had increased and the company was doing surprisingly better than they had been for years. All things considered, the CEO of the company was telling the public that his company was doing great and they should check out the company again. What a nice suggestion.

I did not think about this commercial again until I was skimming through articles on news websites and found one on foxnews.com that caught my eye. This article criticizes the commercial I saw not too long ago. It took the flamboyant language of Ed Whitacre and cut it into small pieces. This foxnews.com article shared with the public that GM essentially stretches the truth in the commercial. The articles shares the thoughts of many sources including a spokesperson for GM and a few Senators. Senator Grassley states that "The bottom line seems to be that the TARP loans were 'repaid' with other TARP funds in a Treasury escrow account. The TARP loans were not repaid from money GM is earning selling cars, as GM and the administration have claimed in their speeches, press releases and television commercials," he wrote. That statement alone made me instantly mad when I thought about how many 1000s of television viewers were being affected and mislead by the content of this commercial. Senator Grassley essentially sheds lights on GM's secret, or "white lie" if you will. In addition to this thought, I could not help but think about how many other people do not read online news and that nothing will probably be done to correct the misleading information Whitacre shared with the masses.

This is a prime example of how authority makes audiences assume credibility. Because Whitacre was the CEO of GM, as an audience member, I automatically assumed he was being honest and forthright with the customers. I mean for the past few years I have heard nothing besides a desperate plea for GM to get more business. However, to find out that he really is just flowering up the truth frustrates me. Their company is not doing better, they are just shifting funds around hoping that somehow a "new and improved" but in my opinion "tainted, tarnished, and untruthful" image will help them. I hope something is done to expose the truth behind Whitacre's statements. He should be reprimanded for his actions and lies, and forced to explain to the public how GM truly did "pay off their bailout money in full, five years before they were supposed to."

Thursday, April 22, 2010

Local and Online Oil Rig Perceptions

I just turned on the television and caught the beginning of the 10:00p.m. news at home. For the most part, I do not watch television, nor do I care to invest tons of my time sitting on my behind looking at a piece of plastic. However, since a young age, I have always enjoyed "being in the know." According this news broadcast, an oil rig off the coast of Louisiana has sunk and there are 11 missing crew members from the accident.
In this post, I will compare and contrast the broadcast of the story from the local news side to that of Fox News online. The 10:00p.m. news station I was watching was KFLY channel 10 out of Lafayette, Louisiana. This story was particularly compelling because it hits close to home. I know many people who work on oil rigs and seemingly a large portion of gentlemen in Louisiana work in this field. Knowing some thing about oil rigs is almost as common as knowing what a "crawfish" is in Louisiana. I"m laughing because after I wrote crawfish the incorrect spelling squiggly immediately popped up.

Getting back on track, this nightly local news broadcast was shared the the public through the voice of a very concerned news anchor. He voice was filled with sympathy and compassion as she shared about the sequence of events. Majority of the story was spent talking about how the events played out and what time the rig sank. The story was told through the flashing of four aerial photographs from the beginning when the problems began, to a few flames sparking shooting up from the rig, to it billowing out black smoke and falling into the Gulf of Mexico with high fire flames, and the last picture was the rig after it had just sunk into the Gulf. The news anchor, a woman, continued to share about the "heart wrenching photographs" and then a spokesperson for the company talked about how "their hearts went out for the families of the missing 11 people, and that they were working to do the best they could to figure out what all happened." This spokesman, simliar to the news anchor woman was very compassionate and spoke with a slow almost monotoned voice as he held his composure. The broadcast then shifted to a computer generated graphic which replicated the rig and offered possible explanations of what happened to the rig with supports falling and the underground work affecting the rig itself. They explained how the underground workings were probably the result of the structure buckling and falling. The last thing the broadcast shared was a slide that took up the television screen and shared how many people were missing, how many gallons of oil they thought had spilled into the Gulf, and how many possible gallons could be spilled if the rig leaked. There could possibly be 700,000 gallons of diesel fuel leaked into the Gulf if the containers began leaking. The anchor optimistically encouraged viewers that oil cleaners could clean up to 171,000 barrels of oil per day out of the Gulf before it reached the coastline of Louisiana. Overall, the broadcaster's tone was a sense of urgency combined with compassion and sympathy. She spoke softly and sympathetically. The overall tone of the broadcast was that this was a horrible accident that will take a long time to recover from, but have hope citizens of Louisiana. There will be help available and something good will come from this event.

However, the tone of the Fox News article was rather abrupt and short. By the time I wrote the paragraph above, Fox News has changed the title of the article and its contents to focus more on the missing victims. This is slightly frustrating but intriguing all at the same time. The previous article on Fox News.com was very vague and focused mainly on how the sinking of the rig was going to affect the environment sharing that something had to be done before it reached the coastline. They were a little less optimistic about the containers not leaking. They also added a dash of suspense in the article by sharing that there was 3-hours of lap time from when the distress called was made and when the rig began severely burning, but that the Coast Guard had gone out to help the rig anyway. The article emphasized that there was going to be indepth research of what happened during that 3 hours of lag time and why more help was not asked of the crew immediately.
The article compared the experience of being on the rig during the explosion like being in war. They interviewed a few local people who were missing loved ones and the grandmother of one of the possible victims shared that "they told us there isn't much hope." Language like this makes this article definitely more emotion felt than the news anchor's sympathetic voice. I guess the text of internet articles leave the tone up for the reader to decided. There is drama packed all in this short article. Every sentence is written to captivate the audience's attention and make the reader wonder what next? How will Louisiana coastlines be affected by the oil spills? What happened during those three hours when communication was limited? Whereas, the local news broadcast left the audience certain that everything was being done to make the situation better.

Perhaps one reason the content of these two articles are different is because the people of South Louisiana needed to feel a sense of comfort and the readers of FoxNews.com that know little about the culture of South Louisiana or the popularity of working "on the rigs" need this story to be engaging to be worth reading.

I found it quite odd that the first article I had read was no longer on the mainpage of FoxNews.com, but now the headline reads, "WHERE ARE THEY? Hope dims for 11 missing workers" Again heartfelt language captivates the audience and once again the media is used to tell a large group of people how to feel. The content change of stories in mere five minutes shows truly what a Global Village our world is becoming through the use of computers and new and developing technologies. I am still sitting here relatively shocked that the article I just read has been completely replaced by a more dramatic article. However, I guess that is how the cookie crumbles, and "when it bleeds, it leads."