Thursday, April 22, 2010

Local and Online Oil Rig Perceptions

I just turned on the television and caught the beginning of the 10:00p.m. news at home. For the most part, I do not watch television, nor do I care to invest tons of my time sitting on my behind looking at a piece of plastic. However, since a young age, I have always enjoyed "being in the know." According this news broadcast, an oil rig off the coast of Louisiana has sunk and there are 11 missing crew members from the accident.
In this post, I will compare and contrast the broadcast of the story from the local news side to that of Fox News online. The 10:00p.m. news station I was watching was KFLY channel 10 out of Lafayette, Louisiana. This story was particularly compelling because it hits close to home. I know many people who work on oil rigs and seemingly a large portion of gentlemen in Louisiana work in this field. Knowing some thing about oil rigs is almost as common as knowing what a "crawfish" is in Louisiana. I"m laughing because after I wrote crawfish the incorrect spelling squiggly immediately popped up.

Getting back on track, this nightly local news broadcast was shared the the public through the voice of a very concerned news anchor. He voice was filled with sympathy and compassion as she shared about the sequence of events. Majority of the story was spent talking about how the events played out and what time the rig sank. The story was told through the flashing of four aerial photographs from the beginning when the problems began, to a few flames sparking shooting up from the rig, to it billowing out black smoke and falling into the Gulf of Mexico with high fire flames, and the last picture was the rig after it had just sunk into the Gulf. The news anchor, a woman, continued to share about the "heart wrenching photographs" and then a spokesperson for the company talked about how "their hearts went out for the families of the missing 11 people, and that they were working to do the best they could to figure out what all happened." This spokesman, simliar to the news anchor woman was very compassionate and spoke with a slow almost monotoned voice as he held his composure. The broadcast then shifted to a computer generated graphic which replicated the rig and offered possible explanations of what happened to the rig with supports falling and the underground work affecting the rig itself. They explained how the underground workings were probably the result of the structure buckling and falling. The last thing the broadcast shared was a slide that took up the television screen and shared how many people were missing, how many gallons of oil they thought had spilled into the Gulf, and how many possible gallons could be spilled if the rig leaked. There could possibly be 700,000 gallons of diesel fuel leaked into the Gulf if the containers began leaking. The anchor optimistically encouraged viewers that oil cleaners could clean up to 171,000 barrels of oil per day out of the Gulf before it reached the coastline of Louisiana. Overall, the broadcaster's tone was a sense of urgency combined with compassion and sympathy. She spoke softly and sympathetically. The overall tone of the broadcast was that this was a horrible accident that will take a long time to recover from, but have hope citizens of Louisiana. There will be help available and something good will come from this event.

However, the tone of the Fox News article was rather abrupt and short. By the time I wrote the paragraph above, Fox News has changed the title of the article and its contents to focus more on the missing victims. This is slightly frustrating but intriguing all at the same time. The previous article on Fox News.com was very vague and focused mainly on how the sinking of the rig was going to affect the environment sharing that something had to be done before it reached the coastline. They were a little less optimistic about the containers not leaking. They also added a dash of suspense in the article by sharing that there was 3-hours of lap time from when the distress called was made and when the rig began severely burning, but that the Coast Guard had gone out to help the rig anyway. The article emphasized that there was going to be indepth research of what happened during that 3 hours of lag time and why more help was not asked of the crew immediately.
The article compared the experience of being on the rig during the explosion like being in war. They interviewed a few local people who were missing loved ones and the grandmother of one of the possible victims shared that "they told us there isn't much hope." Language like this makes this article definitely more emotion felt than the news anchor's sympathetic voice. I guess the text of internet articles leave the tone up for the reader to decided. There is drama packed all in this short article. Every sentence is written to captivate the audience's attention and make the reader wonder what next? How will Louisiana coastlines be affected by the oil spills? What happened during those three hours when communication was limited? Whereas, the local news broadcast left the audience certain that everything was being done to make the situation better.

Perhaps one reason the content of these two articles are different is because the people of South Louisiana needed to feel a sense of comfort and the readers of FoxNews.com that know little about the culture of South Louisiana or the popularity of working "on the rigs" need this story to be engaging to be worth reading.

I found it quite odd that the first article I had read was no longer on the mainpage of FoxNews.com, but now the headline reads, "WHERE ARE THEY? Hope dims for 11 missing workers" Again heartfelt language captivates the audience and once again the media is used to tell a large group of people how to feel. The content change of stories in mere five minutes shows truly what a Global Village our world is becoming through the use of computers and new and developing technologies. I am still sitting here relatively shocked that the article I just read has been completely replaced by a more dramatic article. However, I guess that is how the cookie crumbles, and "when it bleeds, it leads."

No comments:

Post a Comment