Saturday, April 24, 2010

Babies having Babies

Yesterday evening I was reading through the title of articles on foxnews.com when I read

one title that caught my eye. It read, " 11 Year old Mexican 'Rape' Victim wants to keep baby." The article was written by Jana Winter on April 23rd. This articles caught my attention for more than one reason: 1) How did an 11 year old get pregnant? 2) Why does it matter that she is Mexican? 3) I will be teaching in a classroom with students around the age of 11, I should immerse myself in the harsh realities of babies having babies.

First off, this young girl lives in Mexico and is the victim of rape. She was raped supposedly by her stepfather when she was 10 resulting in pregnancy. As I continue reading through the article, it shared about Mexico City's abortion law which allows abortions to be done in the first three months of a pregnancy. Because the actual date of conception was unknown, parties for her aborting the unborn baby encourage he to go ahead and have the procedure done. However, the child has decided to keep the baby. It seems that the young girl has become the poster child for abortions in the country to some degree for those advocating legalizing abortions and abortion rights.

However, the story tends to paint the child as a Mother Mary figure. There is not much discussion about what happens to her stepfather other than the mother pressed charges and he is in jail. When interviewing the mother, she mainly just states that "We are keeping the baby." I love that she says it like that, not. We are keeping the baby? Nonetheless, this young 11 year old girl has been taken from her home. The article paints the picture that the family is impoverished and as a result the young girl is being closely monitored and fed lots of nutrients and vitamins to ensure a healthy pregnancy. Instead of the mother showing any sort of remorse about the situation of her daughter, she states in the article that she "isn't sure it was her husband that did this to her daughter."

When they asked the daughter, not the mom what they were going to do, WInter says that "

She said they were asked of their plans and the girl immediately said, “We’re going to have a baby.”

The mother said she was planning on registering the child as her own, then turned to the girl and said, “It’s going to be like a little brother.”

The girl responded, “But it’s going to be my baby anyway.”

I can't help but think perhaps Winter used "immediately" to help readers understand that maybe the girl had been brainwashed to just respond with that answer. Winter follows with her interaction with the child and mother. To some degree, the child must understand that although her mother wants to seemingly cover up her daughter's baby as her little sibling could be an indication that the mother is embarassed. I find it ironic that he 11 year old child says "it's going to be my baby anyway." It is like she (the 11 year old) already has some grasp on the concept that she is pregnant.

Another disturbing portion of this article came when a woman named Mancera, who is helping the child with coping with pregnancy while offering her other options, like adoptions says that "She is very into motherhood." Sure at 11 years old a little girl should be into motherhoood and playing with her dolls, pretending to be their mother, not preganant with one. An 11 year old "being into motherhood" does not make her fit to be a mother. However, as I previously mentioned the article portrays the young girl as confident in her decision and supposedly ready to be a mother. It paints the mother as in denial and attempting to ignore the fact her husband raped her daughter at the age of 10 and then the father is painted as someone who just happens to be behind bars for the incident.

The framing of this article leaves the reader uncertain of what the true focus is. However, each party is framed in a certain light. The daughter is left to deal with an unfortunate circumstance, the mother is too, and the father is being closed off. However, out of sight does not mean out of mind.

No comments:

Post a Comment